Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Motor Speed Selection
#1

I have been reading up on proxy GT3 race series around the world. Unlike the UK ones, some of the series have a free choice on motors and motor speeds, and that got me wondering...

On the assumption that you can adjust the gears on a car to achieve a required top speed, what would be the different characteristics felt between installing a 30k / 200 g*cm motor over a 20k / 200 g*cm motor in your slot car?

I love puttering with gears
Quote
#2
Smile 

Jeremy,
You will find lots of discussion and disagreement on this subject. 

For me, the base assumption you make isn't right. 
Gearing is a factor or Torque, not of RPM.

Two motors of the same GCM rating will pull the same gear irrespective of the RPM at which they top out.
So when removing a King25 from a car and fitting a King30, I would not change the gearing INITIALLY.

However, the reason I change to a higher RPM is wholly down to speed down the main straight.
Yes, I know "races are won in the corners, not on the straight", BUT the main straight is by far the safest place to pass a car in an adjacent lane, especially in open wheel racing.

If you are thinking about a higher RPM motor because your car doesn't have any "punch" out of the corners , its likely that the motor you have is overgeared or is just not a good specimen. Test it! 

Some food for thought:
High RPM motors are really only useful on large tracks with long straights. 
Is the proxy track large? 
Maybe the proxies have no motor restrictions because the shorter tracks means that no advantage can be gained by a higher RPM motor. 

I've never raced proxies but it intrigues me. How to set a car up for a track you've never touched? 
For me , tuning is a process of continual evolution. Build, test, tune, test, tune, test, tune, test, tune.....
How to do that for a proxy?

You may find that the biggest challenge is not motors and gearing, it's TRACTION.
Getting the right tyres and preparing them for the track surface may well be your biggest challenge especially if it's not identical to your test track or local club track.

So back to your initial assumption: 
If you lower the gearing on a higher RPM motor , you put more effective torque to the wheels and this will exacerbate any shortfall in traction that your car has. Increasing torque beyond the capability of the tyres will make the car harder to handle and lengthen lap times. 

Alan
(Waiting for the rocks to start being thrown)  Bigsmile
[+] 3 members Like Nonfractal's post
Quote
#3

None from me!

In the absence of being able to test on the proxy tracks, I thought the next best thing is to analyse what the gearing was, which then highlighted the range of motor speeds, which then got me curious.

So I'm going to tabulate the numbers to see what the successful cars were running and the less successful ones. and see, if indeed, it was about these numbers.

I love puttering with gears
Quote
#4

And what seems to happen with the proxy is that they tune the cars over the winter, and race them in the Summer, and repeat the process on an annual basis. So same as yours Alan, just a longer cycle. 

Hence my challenge to myself to try and establish a robust starting point based on historical data. 

But your summary picks up on what I am trying to get my head round...if you gear down a high revving motor for limiting top speed, and consequently up the torque at the wheel, why not go for a slower speed, touquey motor to start with...?

I love puttering with gears
Quote
#5

I hosted a round of the GT-3 proxy here last year, most of the cars had 25-30K motors but were geared down to where their top speed was about what you would achieve with most 21.5k motors but with better acceleration and braking. 
  I enjoyed these cars so much that I built a Scaleauto Corvette to the same specs. I didn't have a 25-30K motor so I used a 21.5 and geared it a bit lower than usual. I could have probably qualified it mid pack, But I could never drive it like that lap after lap. These cars were great. The greatest difference that separated the top of the pack from the bottom was smoothness and drivability rather than just speed.
[+] 1 member Likes Mitch58's post
Quote
#6

Hi Mitch

Thanks for the input. In these 'remote' times, the [HRW] Proxy GT3 offers a vast range of car and performance data. That is too tempting a carrot for someone like me who is at the start of their slot car journey (a bit late in life) as it seems to give out all the clues you need to create a fast car. Obviously I am not so naive that I realise there is also some black art at work on tyres, weight distribution and other little things that people don't shout too much about. But you have hinted at what I am thinking is one of the drivers for motor speed choice...

Does a 30k / 200gcm motor geared down to match the top speed of a 20k / 300gcm motor, provide identical acceleration and braking to the slower motor, or is something else happening that creates a difference between the two?

I love puttering with gears
Quote
#7

Speaking  from the  point  of  some  one  who  has  both  organised  and  had  a  fair amount  of  success  in proxy  racing  over  the  years I'll  chuck  in my  views .
DONT be  over impressed by hi performance motors
 
DO make sure   your  car  is    easy  to  drive as  not  all  drivers  will  have  the  same  skill  level 

REMEMBER grip  is  king, if  the  power doesn't  get  onto  the  track  the  fastest motor  in the  world  isn't  going  to  make  the  car  a winner

RELIABILITY a car that  need constant attention wont win 

STRENGTH  Build  your  car  strong enough to  withstand  abuse 

TEST  your  car  before  you  send  it .

PACK it  well 

Lastly good  luck
[+] 2 members Like Grah1's post
Quote
#8

Borne,

The two cars being equal or similar the one with the faster motors and lower gears will have quicker acceleration coming out of a corner and better braking going in. Since the typical home track is small and twisty this is a great advantage. On a large commercial type track with long straights and long fast sweeping curves the advantage would be less but you could still run a bit deeper into the corner and be a bit quicker coming out
 If you're building something for your home track make it fit that track. If your building for a club race check the specs, they often limit gear ratios and motor speeds to keep the racing closer.
 The real key is the handling, weight, balance and most importantly the tires.
  For the grandkids I took three of my older Slot Its and put in H&R 18K motors, these have become my favorite cars to flail around the track.
, and make for some very close racing.

Back to the GT-3 proxy cars. On my 70' track anything under 8seconds is considered quick, anything under 7 seconds is fast. These cars were all in the 6s and the top 5 cars I believe were in the high 5s. I qualified them all myself, and the quickest cars were extremely smooth in the corners rather than just faster. The racing was done by three drivers and they all enjoyed them.
[+] 1 member Likes Mitch58's post
Quote


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread / Author Replies Views Last Post
Last Post by autoavia
21st-Oct-20, 08:43 AM
Last Post by Grah1
15th-Sep-20, 06:33 PM
Last Post by Newt
29th-Jun-20, 06:48 PM
Last Post by Scuderia_Turini
25th-Sep-19, 07:04 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)